$899,000.00
621 W 59TH St, ERIECITY PA 16509
| 3.00 | 5650 ft2
Commercial Industrial Commercial/Sale
Feb. 7, 2026, 12:25 a.m.
Church property in Millcreek Township consisting of two parcels totaling approx. 4.7 acres. The property includes a 5,650 SF church building featuring a sanctuary accommodating approx. 120–150 occupants, four classrooms, a nursery, office space, and three restrooms (men’s, women’s, and handicap-accessible). A single-family residence (parsonage) is also on the parcel. Site features a paved parking lot installed in 2017 with stormwater management, serving approx. 68–75 vehicles. An open pavilion is located toward the rear for gatherings or storage. Interior updates include flooring, paint, and restroom improvements. Legal address: 621 W 59th St; commonly known as 5865 Carriage Hill Dr. Buyers encouraged to contact Millcreek Township zoning re: permitted uses.
Listed by: Tim Bogdanets (814) 835-1200, Howard Hanna Erie Southwest (814) 835-1200
Source: MLS#: 189540; Originating MLS: Greater Erie Board of Realtors
| Directions | Cherry Street Extension to west on Young Road, south on Carriage Hill Drive. Property on left. |
| Year Built | 1969 |
| Area | 7 - Millcreek E of I-79 |
| Water | Public |
| School Districts | Millcreek |
| Building Information | Existing Structure |
| Construction | Brick,Frame |
| Fuel Type | Gas |
| Heating Type | Forced-Air |
Street View
Send your inquiry